About Us
Cara brings a lifetime of experience to the training pen. Raised in the show world and riding since the age of four, she’s built her career through hard work, hands-on involvement, and a deep understanding of what it takes to develop both horses and riders. Her education at the University of Findlay sharpened her knowledge of equine business and management, while her time working under respected industry leaders gave her real-world experience riding, managing, and preparing horses for competition. Cara’s reputation is built on consistency, attention to detail, and a strong commitment to doing things the right way — every time.
About Us
Our Promise
At Cara Stewart Performance Horses, we’re committed to producing broke, competitive, and consistent horses through honest training, high standards, and a results-driven approach. We believe in building confident riders, respectful partnerships, and a program rooted in horsemanship that truly matters. Whether you're looking to show for the first time or aiming for your next big win, our mission is to get you and your horse fully prepared, mentally, physically, and effectively.
Don't Just Hear It From Us
Alyssa S.
“Working with CSPH has been an incredible experience. Watching Cara grow as a trainer while being part of her program has been nothing short of inspiring. Even in a short time, she made significant progress with my ApHC gelding—improvements I didn’t think were possible so quickly. I can’t say enough good things about Cara’s dedication, knowledge, and the care she puts into every horse she touches.”
Miranda G.
“Before I started working with Cara, I was seriously considering leaving the horse world altogether. Now, I’m setting goals, dreaming of buckles, and becoming more involved in the associations I once felt I would never be apart of. It’s entirely thanks to her. She sold one of my horses and found the perfect gelding to help me reach my goals. Cara never makes me feel inadequate for not knowing something. She answers every question, no matter how off-the-wall, with patience and kindness. Whether it’s life or horses, she meets me where I’m at and will explain things hundreds of different ways if that’s what it takes. I truly couldn’t ask for a better trainer, and I feel so lucky to have found her.”
Delaney L.
"I have only been riding with Cara for about two months, but the growth I've seen in both myself and my horse is incredible. Before working with Cara, I honestly wasn't sure if I ever wanted to show anymore. But after just one show under her guidance, that spark I thought I'd lost came rushing back. She really wants to help reach the goals she had me set for myself. Cara even will even point out something good you did even after a bad ride. I can't thank Cara enough for everything she has done and continues to do for me and my horse! I couldn't have asked for a better trainer!"